UK House of Lords debate highlights tension over Jewish community security
A Sikh peer faced significant backlash after suggesting that British Jewish silence on Gaza contributed to rising antisemitic violence.
By Bianca Shevchenko ·

Lord Indarjit Singh of Wimbledon faced audible criticism during a House of Lords debate on Tuesday after attributing a rise in antisemitism in the United Kingdom to the attitudes of British Jewry. The incident drew sharp condemnation from fellow peers and community leaders, who described his remarks as disgraceful. The controversy erupted during a discussion focused on how the government can better protect Jewish community buildings, which are currently facing heightened risks from attacks.
In his address, Singh claimed that the threat to the British Jewish community has undoubtedly increased due to what he called the community's inexplicable silence regarding the actions of the Israeli military in Gaza. He stated that antisemitic attacks have risen because British Jews failed to condemn these military actions. The peer, who identifies as Sikh, further argued from his own perspective that Palestinians in Gaza, including those in tents destroyed by floods and care workers harassed by soldiers, are suffering without fault of their own. He asked the minister if the House agreed that these groups also deserved sympathy and practical support.
This was not the first instance of Singh holding the Jewish community accountable for antisemitic incidents. In April, he had previously asked the House if it would help the image and security of Jewish people if they issued a strong statement dissociating themselves from the policies of the Netanyahu government. He described the people of Gaza as human beings suffering from atrocities, suggesting that such a statement would be beneficial.
Other members of the House of Lords reacted with shock to the sentiment. Baroness Ruth Deech, a Jewish peer, countered Singh's argument by noting that the British Jewish community is in a perilous situation. She emphasized the need for round-the-clock protection following a series of assaults, arson attacks, and increasingly violent protests. She highlighted that the community does not have the luxury of making political statements while under physical threat.
The debate occurred against a backdrop of significant government spending on security. The UK government has allocated approximately 32.4 million pounds towards protecting Jewish synagogues, schools, and care homes. However, peers warned that this funding primarily covers the cost of security guards. Jewish communities are often left to finance large sums for reinforced doors, bomb-proof glass, and security alarm systems themselves.
Community leaders have accused Singh's comments of contributing to the broader climate of antisemitism. Claudia Mendoza, chief executive of the Jewish Leadership Council, stated that for a member of the House of Lords to suggest British Jews brought attacks upon themselves is reprehensible. She noted that British Jews are not responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, regardless of their political opinions. She added that such rhetoric risks emboldening those who seek to intimidate and attack Jewish people in Britain.
Lord Ian Austin, a former Labour minister, called the remarks completely disgusting. He described the suggestion that British Jews are responsible for the rise in antisemitism as one of the oldest antisemitic tropes. Austin argued that it is plainly ludicrous to hold the community accountable for attacks based on their relationship with a foreign government.
Recent data underscores the severity of the situation. The UK Home Office recorded 1,926 antisemitic hate crimes in the first six months of the year. This figure indicates that Jewish people are nine times more likely to be victims of a hate crime than their Muslim counterparts. Additionally, the Community Security Trust, a charity dedicated to protecting British Jews, recorded more than 3,700 antisemitic incidents in 2025, marking a slight increase from the previous year.
In 2026, several arson attacks targeted London's Jewish communities. A prominent incident in March involved the burning of four volunteer Hatzola UK ambulances parked in Golders Green, a predominantly Jewish neighborhood. Three synagogues in London were also targeted by arsonists in April and May, along with a local Jewish charity. In June, an empty pram was set alight in the stairwell of an apartment building in Golders Green. This occurred just two months after an attacker stabbed two Jewish men in the same area.






