AdvertiseDonate
Headlines Times · 3597 East Monarch Sky Lane, Suite 240, Meridian, ID 83646

Chris Columbus Expresses Doubt About New Home Alone Sequel Despite Disney Announcement

The director of the original 1990 film stated that a new installment faces significant challenges following the death of co-star Catherine O'Hara, even as Disney confirmed a project with Macaulay Culkin.

By Marco Ortega ·

Illustration for: Chris Columbus Expresses Doubt About New Home Alone Sequel Despite Disney Announcement
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Chris Columbus, the director of the 1990 classic, was unaware that a new Home Alone film was in the works until the very last moment. Speaking with Variety just minutes before Disney officially announced the development of a new installment, Columbus expressed his views on the franchise's future. He noted that any attempt to revive the series faces a steep uphill battle in the absence of Catherine O'Hara, who played Kevin McCallister's mother in the original film.

O'Hara passed away on January 30 at the age of 71. Columbus emphasized her importance to the movie's identity, describing her and Macaulay Culkin as the yin and yang of the story. He stated that without both actors, the film loses its emotional core. He explained that O'Hara constitutes half of the movie's essence, and together with Culkin, they create the emotional epicenter that defines the narrative.

The new project, which was announced on Friday, is being shaped by writers Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg. They are working alongside Culkin and will produce the film through their Point Grey banner. According to reports, the plot will follow an older Kevin from his perspective as a father. The film is currently in early development, with specific plot details and casting choices remaining confidential for now.

When Variety followed up with Columbus after the news broke, he declined to offer additional comments. However, he previously expressed enthusiasm regarding Culkin's recent return to the public eye. The actor appeared in a holiday commercial for McDonald's released on November 17, a role that Columbus praised warmly. He stated that he hopes to collaborate with Culkin again, though he acknowledged that the next project might not necessarily be related to the Home Alone franchise.

Despite his initial skepticism, Columbus left the possibility open for a reunion that centers on the original ensemble cast. He argued that the success of the first film relied heavily on the specific chemistry between the actors, comparing the dynamic to the cast of The Goonies. He expressed frustration with previous sequels that attempted to replicate the original's magic without understanding why that particular group of performers worked so effectively together.

The Home Alone franchise has continued without its original stars in several subsequent releases. These include Home Alone 3 in 1997, Home Alone 4 in 2002, Home Alone: The Holiday Heist in 2012, and Disney+'s Home Sweet Home Alone in 2021. Columbus has often been critical of these later entries, particularly those that did not involve the original creative team or lead actors.

Columbus also highlighted the irreplaceable nature of the film's comedic villains, Harry and Marv. Played by Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci, these characters are considered the ultimate comic duo for the story. He noted that subsequent sequels have struggled to match the undefinable chemistry between Stern and Pesci, a quality that he believes is difficult to replicate in new productions.

This latest development comes after Columbus had previously called another Home Alone a mistake in interviews last year. In 2020, he described Disney's planned reboot at the time as a waste of time, noting that he had not been consulted for that project. That reboot eventually became Home Sweet Home Alone. Now, with the new announcement, the focus shifts to how the writers will navigate the legacy of the original cast.

Seth Rogen also shares a personal connection to the late actress. O'Hara portrayed the studio executive Patty Leigh in his Apple TV comedy series The Studio. She was still holding that role when she died. O'Hara had also spoken at Culkin's Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony in December 2023, underscoring the close ties between these figures in the film industry.

Looking ahead, Columbus is preparing to direct Gremlins 3, which is scheduled to begin filming early next year. He is also executive producing Werwulf, a horror film directed by Robert Eggers. Focus Features is set to release that movie on December 25, marking another significant addition to Columbus's upcoming slate of projects.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Headlines Times in your inboxReporting on the stories people talk about. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Headlines Times in your inboxReporting on the stories people talk about. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.