AdvertiseDonate
Headlines Times · 3597 East Monarch Sky Lane, Suite 240, Meridian, ID 83646

Senator Slotkin Challenges DOJ Inquiry Over Political Speech

A Michigan senator argues that a federal investigation into her remarks on congressional oversight violates her First Amendment rights and constitutional protections.

By Marco Ortega ·

Illustration for: Senator Slotkin Challenges DOJ Inquiry Over Political Speech
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan has formally challenged a Justice Department official regarding an ongoing inquiry into her political statements. The Democratic lawmaker, who has faced increased scrutiny from the Trump administration, described the investigation as baseless in a letter obtained by NBC News. This dispute highlights a growing tension between elected officials and federal prosecutors over the limits of political speech.

Slotkin is one of five Democratic members of Congress who recently received letters from Aaron Reitz, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas. Reitz posted these documents on social media, drawing attention to specific comments Slotkin made about congressional oversight. In the correspondence, he suggested that her remarks regarding oversight acting as a deterrence message to potential administration hires could constitute a criminal civil rights offense.

In her response dated Wednesday, Slotkin asserted that her statements were protected by the First Amendment. She emphasized that freedom of speech is a fundamental right enjoyed by all Americans. Furthermore, she highlighted her role as a United States Senator, noting that conducting oversight is a critical constitutional responsibility that is central to the legislative branch.

The senator also invoked the Speech or Debate clause of the Constitution. She argued that this provision prevents the prosecution of legislators for performing legislative acts or conducting investigations. Consequently, she stated that the threat of an investigation in this context is unfounded and requested that Reitz withdraw his letter immediately.

Slotkin criticized the manner in which the inquiry was announced, noting that Reitz publicly posted the letter rather than sending it directly to her, her legal team, or Senate counsel. She contended that this approach violated Justice Department policy and indicated that the investigation was driven by political ambition and publicity rather than legitimate legal concerns.

Reitz, who is 39 years old, previously served as chief of staff for Senator Ted Cruz of Texas. He assumed his current role as U.S. Attorney over the summer following a fourth-place finish in the Republican primary for Texas attorney general. In addition to Slotkin, Reitz has sent similar letters to other prominent Democrats, including Senators Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, and Adam Schiff of California, as well as Representative Robert Garcia of California.

The U.S. Attorney told NBC News this week that his actions were not intended to chill free speech. However, Slotkin’s attorney, Prett Bharara, had earlier written to Attorney General Todd Blanche. In that letter, Bharara cautioned Blanche against following President Donald Trump’s public instruction to examine Slotkin’s speech, which the President had characterized as a criminal act.

Attorney General Blanche has acknowledged that Slotkin’s words alone did not constitute a crime. During a press conference last week, he stated that there were no ongoing criminal investigations into the words spoken by incoming senators or congressmen. This admission appears to contradict the specific focus of Reitz’s inquiry into the senator’s rhetoric.

In her final remarks, Slotkin suggested that Reitz was either seeking personal attention for himself and the Justice Department or was unaware of basic constitutional principles. She labeled the threats as frivolous and a violation of his ethical duties as an attorney. She concluded by reserving all rights to take appropriate actions in the future regarding what she termed a sham investigation.

This dispute adds to a series of legal challenges faced by Democratic lawmakers. Earlier this year, Slotkin and five other sitting Democrats were targeted by the administration over a social media video aimed at military and intelligence personnel. Although allies of U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro attempted to indict the group for that speech, federal grand jurors unanimously rejected the indictment attempt.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Headlines Times in your inboxReporting on the stories people talk about. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Headlines Times in your inboxReporting on the stories people talk about. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.