Tennessee Highway Patrol settles DUI suit with Wild Orchid member
A $70,000 payout to Stefanie Fair follows blood tests that showed she was sober during her 2024 arrest.
By Marco Ortega ·

The Tennessee Highway Patrol will pay Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, $70,000 to settle a lawsuit over her drunk driving arrest. The state Board of Claims approved the deal, and a spokesman for the attorney general’s office said the money should be sent within the next few weeks.
Fair was arrested in 2024. Trooper Keith Velez told investigators he smelled alcohol inside her vehicle. He described a distinct odor that comes from either the person or the car. Fair, who was eating ice cream before the stop, told investigators she did not drink that night. Video footage of the incident was later released by WSMV4 Investigates.
Blood work collected after the arrest showed Fair was sober. This result was central to the legal dispute. Fair’s attorney, Ben Raybin, said the state has acknowledged that many such arrests are legally weak. He argued that a jury would likely find in favor of the drivers if the cases went to trial.
Tennessee law does not provide a way for sober drivers to recover costs after DUI charges are dismissed. Raybin said the only option for these individuals is to sue the state. Fair is the second sober driver to reach a settlement with the Highway Patrol.
Thomas Manis previously received $75,000 after state troopers arrested him in East Tennessee. Other drivers are also in the process of suing. Labreesha Batey, a NASA employee, and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant have filed claims. Bondurant was the eighth sober driver arrested by state trooper James Zahn. A man from Thompson Station filed a lawsuit this year claiming Zahn arrested him while he was sober, which would make him the ninth.
Court records show that Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office and La Vergne police have also settled lawsuits involving sober drivers. These agreements reflect a growing number of claims against state and local agencies.






