AdvertiseDonate
Headlines Times · 3597 East Monarch Sky Lane, Suite 240, Meridian, ID 83646
Politics · Puget Sound

Judge Blocks Trump Arch Over Arlington, Citing Lack of Congressional Approval

A Virginia federal judge halted the 250-foot structure indefinitely, stating the administration likely cannot win the case on its legal merits.

By Marco Ortega ·

Illustration for: Judge Blocks Trump Arch Over Arlington, Citing Lack of Congressional Approval
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A federal judge in Virginia has indefinitely blocked President Trump’s proposed triumphal arch, ruling that the project is unlikely to succeed in court. District Judge Leonie Brinkema issued a preliminary injunction during a hearing on Friday, halting construction in Memorial Circle while the legal challenge proceeds.

The decision grants the request of Arlington County, which sued in October to stop the development. Democracy Forward, the nonprofit backing the plaintiffs, confirmed the ruling in a statement. Senior counsel Kate Talmor said the court recognized the irreparable harm the project would cause to local residents and workers.

The 250-foot arch is slated for construction in Memorial Circle, a location in Washington, D.C., that sits on the Virginia side of the Potomac River. The site is located near both Arlington National Cemetery and Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport. Arlington County argued the structure would increase noise and air pollution while clogging thoroughfares used by emergency transport services.

County officials also raised concerns about public safety. They stated that if the arch doubles as a military complex, as the administration has suggested, it would require additional county resources. The lawsuit noted that the arch would disrupt historic sightlines between the National Mall and Arlington National Cemetery. It also posed logistical challenges for the 24 to 27 funerals the cemetery holds every weekday.

In a filing last month, the plaintiffs accused the administration of rushing through federally mandated environmental reviews. They argued that the National Environmental Policy Act requires a "hard look" before disruptive ground-disturbing activities begin. The National Park Service defended the review process, which concluded with approval earlier this month. A spokesperson said building the arch elsewhere would defeat its purpose.

Judge Brinkema, a Clinton appointee, suggested the government has a weak case. She told lawyers during the hearing that she did not see "any way" the government could win on the merits. She criticized the administration for relying on a 1925 law that authorized a pair of shorter columns at the same location, a law the administration has not used to seek congressional approval for the new design.

The judge described the project as a "rushed job" and found the government’s analysis of environmental and economic impacts inadequate. She specifically noted concerns about construction cranes, which the government said would be taller than the arch itself, and their impact on airspace. The Federal Aviation Administration stated the arch would not pose a hazard if lit correctly, including with an eternal flame on top.

Aviation safety experts, however, expressed concern that the structure would add risk to an already complex airspace. They noted that military capabilities, which the administration has proposed, were not included in the FAA’s analysis. The Justice Department said it would appeal Brinkema’s decision immediately.

This ruling marks the second legal setback for the arch this week. On Wednesday, D.C. District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended a restraining order that prevents the administration from breaking ground through Dec. 3. That case was brought by a group including Vietnam War veterans and was joined last month by the governments of D.C. and Virginia. Nine Kennedy family members moved to intervene in that case last week.

White House spokesperson Davis Ingle told NPR earlier this week that the administration remains confident in the project. He said the team will continue making the case for the monument as the litigation proceeds. The administration has not yet released a formal response to Brinkema’s specific findings on the environmental review.

More Politics · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Headlines Times in your inboxReporting on the stories people talk about. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Headlines Times in your inboxReporting on the stories people talk about. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.