Washington Budget: Lawmakers weigh options to curb record lawsuit payouts
State officials spent over $537 million resolving claims last year, and a new legislative session begins in January with competing proposals on the table.
By Marco Ortega ·

Washington state lawmakers will return to Olympia in January to evaluate a series of proposals aimed at reducing the financial burden of litigation against public entities. The state Department of Enterprise Services reports that the government spent over $537 million resolving claims in the previous fiscal year, a record high. Defense costs, including legal fees and insurance premiums, added more than $90 million to that total.
The spending pace has accelerated in the current fiscal year. From July through October, the state allocated $196 million for lawsuit payouts and $41 million for legal fees and insurance. According to state figures, this trajectory places total annual costs on a path toward $600 million. Local governments, including counties and school districts, face similar increases in payouts and insurance premiums, diverting funds from services such as police, fire protection, and education.
A state panel spent several months analyzing the crisis before the Legislature adjourned for 2026 in March. The group produced a menu of options, but stakeholders remain divided on the best course of action. Sen. Manka Dhingra, a Democrat from Redmond and chair of the Law and Justice Committee, noted that the decision now rests with the Legislature. “It really is upon us to decide, given the menu of options, where we want to go,” Dhingra said.
Derek Young, executive director of the Washington State Association of Counties, argued that immediate action is required. “We need significant changes, and it has to happen now,” Young stated. “I just refuse to believe that this Legislature is going to allow their governments to fail.” The claims driving the fiscal strain include discrimination cases and failures in child welfare, with many involving childhood sexual abuse in the foster care system. Court decisions over the past decade have expanded state liability, while jury verdicts continue to grow. In the spring, a Pierce County jury ordered the state and a day care center to pay $130 million for the death of a toddler.
The majority of the state committee, representing government interests, recommends imposing a cap on damage awards. Washington is one of the few states without such a limit. Tyna Ek, general counsel for the Washington Schools Risk Management Pool, said a cap on non-economic damages would allow claimants to be compensated while preventing the bankruptcy of public resources. However, Dhingra expressed hesitation, stating, “I personally struggle a lot with a cap on damages to survivors. I don’t think you can put a dollar figure on the type of abuse.”
Another legal concept under review is joint and several liability. This rule allows plaintiffs to recover the full amount of damages from any defendant at fault, regardless of their degree of responsibility. The committee’s majority report suggests limiting this liability unless a government entity’s responsibility exceeds a specific threshold, such as 25%. Young described the current system as making the government an insurer for the misconduct of others. “This is the crazy part. If we were struggling with something that nobody else had figured out, I could understand,” he said.
Advocates for plaintiffs, including Rhea Yo of Legal Counsel for Youth and Children, argue that the focus should be on preventing harm rather than limiting payouts. “The primary focus is how do we make sure the judgments are lower,” Yo said. Her group proposes trauma-informed training, better staffing at the Department of Children, Youth and Families, and lower caseloads to reduce the root causes of liability. They also support expanding an early resolution program within the state attorney general’s office to facilitate quicker settlements.
The Legislature already spent $1 billion to stabilize the state’s liability account this year, but another infusion is likely necessary. Proposed legislation requiring arbitration to speed up cases failed to pass earlier this year, a move opposed by trial lawyers. Tyna Ek warned that attorneys will likely oppose recommendations that mitigate costs. “In order for the Legislature to fix the problem,” Ek said, “it’s going to take a lot of political will and courage.”
Gov. Bob Ferguson is reviewing the panel’s recommendations. His office stated he is evaluating the proposals ahead of the 105-day legislative session, which begins on January 11. Dhingra said she expects the governor to engage with the debate and expressed optimism that the Legislature will make progress on these issues.






